The expensive part of choosing an e-commerce platform often shows up after launch.
A B2C e-commerce platform may fit the store you have today, then become harder to work with as you add new sales channels, subscriptions, custom checkout rules, or connections to ERP and other systems.
For DTC brands, the choice carries even more weight because the brand owns more of the customer journey and more of the systems behind it.
This guide compares the major platforms from the implementation side: what they cost to own, how they connect with the rest of your commerce stack, when headless is worth the extra work, and which business setups each platform suits.
What DTC changes in the platform decision
B2C tells you who buys: an individual customer. DTC tells you how the sale happens: the brand sells its own products directly to that customer, without a retailer or wholesaler handling the transaction.
That difference changes who owns the work around the sale. In DTC e-commerce, a brand runs the checkout, collects customer data, manages returns and service, and often handles subscriptions, customer accounts, and retention itself.
Many DTC brands also sell through retailers or marketplaces. Once those channels run side by side, inventory and orders need to stay in sync across all of them.
| Selling through retail partners | Selling through your own DTC store | |
| Checkout | The retailer runs the customer checkout | The brand runs the checkout |
| Customer data | Access depends on the retailer and commercial agreement | The brand collects first-party customer and order data, subject to consent and privacy rules |
| Returns | The retailer usually handles returns for purchases made through its channel | The brand defines and manages the return process |
| Fulfillment | The retailer, brand, or a logistics partner may fulfill the order | The brand coordinates fulfillment itself or through a logistics partner |
| Margin and costs | The retail partner takes its share of the sale | More revenue stays with the brand, together with payment, acquisition, fulfillment, and return costs |
That extra ownership is why platform choice matters more in DTC. The platform has to support the processes the brand now runs itself and connect them with the other channels it still uses.
How to evaluate a B2C e-commerce platform
Most B2C platforms can cover the same headline needs. The difference is how they cover the ones your store actually depends on: as a built-in feature, through an app, on a higher plan, or through custom development. Answers to the following questions will help you guide your choice.
How much control do you need over the buying experience?
Start with the parts of the journey that have a direct effect on conversion:
- Checkout flow.
- Mobile UX.
- Promotions and discounts.
- Custom buying rules.
If your store can work within standard templates and checkout flows, a hosted platform will cover a lot with less development work. If the buying journey depends on custom logic or a highly specific mobile experience, check how much can be changed and what that requires in terms of plan level, extensions, or development.
What do subscriptions, returns, and customer accounts need to do?
These features can look identical in a comparison table but work very differently once you add business rules.
For example:
- Subscriptions: pauses, skips, plan changes, failed-payment recovery, self-service.
- Returns: rules based on product type, region, order status, or purchase date.
- Customer accounts: order history, loyalty data, subscriptions, saved payments, B2B access.
The point is to find out how the platform supports the version of the feature you actually need and what has to be added around it.
What does the platform need to connect to?
Map the systems that need to exchange data with the store:
- ERP: inventory, orders, pricing.
- CRM: customer and account data.
- Payment providers: transactions and payment methods.
- Marketing tools: customer events, campaigns, consent.
- Analytics: sales and behavior data.
- Warehouse systems and marketplaces: inventory and order sync.
Then, check whether the integrations already exist, what data they actually support, and what happens when the standard connector does not cover your workflow.
What will the platform cost after launch?
Look beyond the license or monthly subscription. Include:
- Transaction fees.
- Paid apps and extensions.
- Hosting, where relevant.
- Development work.
- Integration work.
- Upgrades.
- Ongoing support and maintenance.
A lower entry price can lose its advantage once several paid apps or regular development work become part of the setup.
How much change do you expect over the next few years?
Look at what is already likely to appear on the roadmap:
- New markets and currencies.
- Additional storefronts.
- Wholesale sales.
- Subscriptions.
- New fulfillment models.
- B2B sales.
If several of these are already planned, check how the platform supports them and what each addition means for development and architecture.
Why specifics matter
Given all of the above, a feature checklist only gets you so far. Two platforms may both support subscriptions, returns, integrations, and multiple storefronts, but one handles them as built-in capabilities while the other relies on apps, higher plans, or custom code. That difference changes the real cost and effort behind the same checkbox.
When headless architecture makes sense
Headless becomes relevant when the standard storefront cannot support an important customer experience, channel, or content model without substantial development around it.
With headless, an e-commerce backend still handles areas such as catalog, pricing, and orders, while the customer-facing front end is built separately. Teams gain more control over that experience and can run several front ends from the same commerce backend. Headless architecture also means a separate front end, an integration layer, and often more services to maintain.
Before building with or migrating to headless, name the customer experience or business requirement that needs it. If the standard storefront already handles it well, the additional engineering effort is unnecessary.
B2C e-commerce solutions to consider
Once you know how much control the store needs and whether a standard storefront is enough, platform differences become easier to read. The same requirement may be included in one platform, depend on an app in another, or require development work in a third.
| Platform | Strong fit | What stands out | Watch out for |
| Shopify | DTC brands that want to launch and change the store quickly | Hosted platform, large app ecosystem, mature checkout | App costs, plan-dependent checkout control, ERP-heavy workflows |
| BigCommerce | Growing brands with more complex commerce needs or B2C and B2B channels | More commerce capabilities in the platform, multi-storefront, API access | B2B Edition costs, connector coverage for existing systems |
| Adobe Commerce | Large stores with complex catalogs, integrations, and custom business rules | High control over commerce logic and integrations | Development, upgrades, infrastructure, and ongoing ownership |
| WooCommerce | Content-led brands already using WordPress | Strong content-commerce fit and control over hosting and extensions | More responsibility for hosting, extensions, performance, and updates |
| Salesforce Commerce Cloud | Global, multi-site, high-volume brands | Multi-site operations, large price-book requirements, Salesforce ecosystem | Higher development requirements and enterprise-level ownership |
The table gives a quick sense of where each platform tends to fit. The differences become more useful once you look at what creates that fit: how much work the platform takes off the team, where extra software enters the picture, and how demanding the store becomes to maintain as requirements grow.
Shopify
Shopify makes a strong case when speed matters. A team can get a consumer store running without taking ownership of hosting or the underlying commerce infrastructure, then add functionality through apps and platform extensions.
The trade-off becomes clearer as requirements get more specific. Checkout UI extensions for the information, shipping, and payment stages require Shopify Plus, and custom development and third-party apps add to the platform cost.
For a growing DTC brand with fairly standard commerce flows, that model can remove a lot of technical work. For a store with unusual checkout logic or deep ERP processes, it is worth checking early which requirements are covered by Shopify itself, which need apps, and which push the store toward Plus or custom development.
BigCommerce
BigCommerce is worth a closer look when multi-storefront or B2B sales are already part of the plan. Multi-storefront is available across its current plans with different storefront limits and fees, while B2B Edition adds company accounts, quotes, invoice management, and purchase-order workflows.
This can keep more commerce functionality within the same platform family. B2B Edition is a separate offering, though, and the systems around the store still need to be checked for connector coverage and any custom integration work.
Adobe Commerce
Adobe Commerce makes more sense when the business already knows it needs a high degree of control over catalog logic, integrations, checkout behavior, or other commerce rules.
That control comes with technical ownership. Adobe Commerce runs across a number of infrastructure dependencies, and third-party extensions need attention during upgrades. Extensions can also affect storefront performance if they are poorly maintained.
For a company with an experienced engineering team and complex commerce operations, that can be a reasonable trade. For a lean DTC team that mainly needs a reliable storefront and common integrations, Adobe Commerce can introduce far more work than the store requires.
WooCommerce
WooCommerce is a natural option for brands whose website already runs on WordPress and where content plays a large role in acquisition and sales. The core platform has no monthly platform fee, and the merchant chooses the hosting, payment provider, and extensions. Those decisions stay with the merchant as the store grows.
This model gives the team more control over where the store runs and what gets added to it. As traffic and operational requirements grow, hosting, extension compatibility, updates, and performance require more attention from the team maintaining the store.
Salesforce Commerce Cloud
Salesforce Commerce Cloud fits global brands managing multiple sites, markets, price books, or existing Salesforce systems. Its current B2C editions range from five sites and ten price books in Growth to 100 sites and 3,500 price books in Plus and Premium. Full Order Management is included in B2C Premium.
Salesforce also offers composable storefronts and headless APIs. B2B Commerce is a separate edition, so brands planning both consumer and business sales should evaluate how those parts will share catalog, pricing, customer, and order data.
Other platforms worth checking
The five platforms above cover a large share of common B2C scenarios, but some businesses will have requirements that point elsewhere.
- commercetools: suited to composable architectures where teams want to assemble the commerce stack from separate services.
- Kibo Commerce: worth considering for more complex omnichannel operations across digital and physical sales.
- Shopware: a possible fit for brands that want more control over the commerce layer and storefront development.
- Odoo: makes more sense when the store needs to sit closely with ERP, inventory, accounting, and other business operations.
- Wix: better suited to smaller stores where simplicity and lower development involvement matter more than deep commerce customization.
These alternatives become more relevant when one requirement carries unusual weight. At that point, the shortlist should follow that requirement rather than the platform’s market share.
What to check before relying on an integration
Knowing which systems need to connect is only half the picture. What matters just as much is how much work those connections require on each platform.
A ready-made connector can save development time, but its presence alone says very little. Check:
- What data moves: orders, inventory, prices, customers, refunds, consent, or only part of that.
- Which way it moves: from the store to the ERP, from the ERP back to the store, or both.
- How quickly it updates: instantly, on a schedule, or only after a manual sync.
- How business rules are handled: different prices by market, split fulfillment, partial refunds, or several inventory locations.
- Who owns failures: what happens when the connection breaks, data duplicates, or one system rejects an update.
This can change the platform choice more than the storefront itself. One option may need custom middleware and regular development to keep everything in sync, while another may already support the same data flows with less work.
That difference shows up later in maintenance, development cost, and how easily the store can change with the rest of the business.
Matching the platform to your situation
A five-person DTC team, a subscription brand, and a retailer with a heavy ERP can all shortlist the same platforms and still need completely different things from them.
#1 First store with a small team
Lean toward Shopify if the priority is getting the store running quickly without taking on hosting and infrastructure. Watch how many apps and higher-tier features become necessary as the store grows, because that is where the initial simplicity can start costing more.
#2 Subscription-led brand
Lean toward a platform with a mature subscription ecosystem and strong account management. Shopify is often a practical choice here because of its app ecosystem, but check the exact subscription flows you need, including pauses, skips, payment recovery, and self-service. Those details usually determine how much third-party software the store will rely on.
#3 Content-led brand on WordPress
Lean toward WooCommerce when editorial content already drives a large part of traffic and sales. It keeps commerce inside the same WordPress environment. Watch the ownership that comes with it: hosting, updates, extension compatibility, and performance all stay with the team maintaining the site.
#4 Complex catalog with ERP-heavy operations
BigCommerce is worth evaluating when SaaS ownership and API access are priorities. Adobe Commerce fits projects where catalog, pricing, checkout, or purchasing rules require deeper customization and the team can support the engineering that comes with it. In both cases, validate the ERP data flows before choosing the storefront platform.
#5 DTC plus wholesale and retail
BigCommerce can cover consumer storefronts and add business purchasing through B2B Edition. Larger multi-site operations already using Salesforce may have a stronger reason to stay within its commerce ecosystem, where B2C and B2B are offered as separate editions. In either case, inventory, pricing, orders, and customer ownership across channels should be mapped before the platform decision.
Your shortlist must’ve gotten shorter by now
By this point, the platforms should look less alike. The differences show up in:
- How they support the flows your store depends on.
- How much extra software sits around them.
- How difficult the integrations are.
- How much work stays with your team after launch.
That is usually enough to narrow the choice to two or three realistic options. From there, the decision gets much more technical: existing systems, data flows, development effort, and the changes already planned for the business.
If you have reached that stage, Vilmate can review the shortlist with you and help work out which option fits the project before implementation starts. Contact our team to discuss the details.
FAQ
B2C describes who buys from the business: an individual consumer. DTC e-commerce describes how the sale happens: the brand sells its own products directly to that consumer.
A brand selling through Amazon is still B2C. The same brand selling through its own store is also operating a DTC channel.
There is no single best B2C e-commerce platform for every DTC brand.
Shopify often fits smaller teams that want a fast launch and a large app ecosystem. WooCommerce can suit content-led brands already using WordPress. BigCommerce becomes more relevant when the store has several channels, storefronts, or more complex integrations. Adobe Commerce and Salesforce Commerce Cloud usually make more sense for larger operations with stronger development resources.
The shortlist should follow the way the business sells, integrates, and plans to grow.
Only if you can name a requirement that your standard storefront cannot support well enough.
That might be a highly custom customer experience, several front ends using the same commerce backend, or tighter control over how commerce and content work together. Headless also means maintaining a separate front end and integration layer, so the added flexibility comes with more development work.
Yes. Some commerce platforms can support consumer and business sales within the same environment.
BigCommerce can combine B2C storefronts with B2B capabilities through B2B Edition. Salesforce offers separate B2C and B2B Commerce editions within the same ecosystem. Adobe Commerce can support both models, with B2B functionality added through Adobe Commerce B2B.
The harder part is usually the shared logic behind them: catalogs, pricing, customer accounts, inventory, orders, and ERP data may work differently for consumer and business buyers.